Op-Ed on FBI’s Post-9/11 Counterterrorism Efforts : RushPRNews - Newswire & Global Press Release Distribution

 
Bookmark and Share

Op-Ed on FBI’s Post-9/11 Counterterrorism Efforts

January 12, 2010

Op-Ed on FBI’s Post-9/11 Counterterrorism Efforts
Twin towers of the World Trade Center burning.

WASHINGTON (RPRN) 01/12/10 — The following op-ed, published on January 11, 2010 in The New York Post, was written by former FBI Assistant Director James Kallstrom. Kallstrom, who is currently a member of the FBI Director’s Advisory Group, was also director of the New York Homeland Security Agency.

Ever since 9/11, critics have suggested that the FBI isn't up to its task as our nation's lead counterterrorism agency.

Yet, as the nation focused on the failures of the intelligence community in the Christmas Day bombing attempt over Detroit, last Friday saw two more arrests in the ongoing FBI investigation of a plot to bomb New York City first exposed by the September arrest of Najibullah Zazi.

It's easy to stand on the periphery, without the benefit of real-world experience, and render judgments with the benefit of hindsight. But counterterrorism cases are extremely complex and often require a relatively quick series of judgments, often with incomplete information. Counterterror investigations and intelligence gathering aren't black and white, simple, or easy.

America went on a war footing against terrorism only after 9/11. Before then, our government viewed international terrorism strictly as a law-enforcement matter, giving the FBI the responsibility to address it. In that period, the FBI had significant accomplishments, including the apprehension of the 1993 World Trade Center bombers within six days; preventing attacks on New York's most important landmarks with the arrest and conviction of the "Blind Sheik;" sending agents in 1998 to East Africa, where they quickly solved the two US embassy bombing cases without the assets normally available to investigators in America; and, in 2000, dispatching agents after the USS Cole bombing to Yemen, where they determined that al Qaeda terrorists had carried out the bombing. During this period, the Justice Department severely and unnecessarily restricted the FBI's ability to share intelligence information, and Congress acted haltingly to properly resource, fund and provide the legal framework for the FBI's counterterrorism program, including new technology required to defend the nation.

Post-9/11, as al Qaeda and other Muslim extremist groups have demonstrated their obsession with radicalizing U.S. Muslims, the FBI has disrupted a number of plots.

While some claim that collecting and analyzing intelligence is a new phenomenon in the FBI culture, in fact, the FBI's intelligence and counterintelligence mission began before World War II and predates the creation of the fabled OSS and the CIA. Indeed, the FBI has long honed the skills and techniques necessary for success in protecting against international terrorism—using informants, undercover operations, and court-ordered electronic surveillance. Historically, the FBI has collected and analyzed information, whether the threat was the Soviet Union, domestic terrorist groups like the Klu Klux Klan, or organized crime.

Yet such critics as Gabriel Schoenfeld (in his Dec. 4 Post op-ed, "The FBI Bungles on Terror Again") assert, "It's high time to look at creating a new and separate domestic counterterrorism…agency along the lines of Great Britain's MI5."

In evaluating this naive and discredited suggestion, we need to consider the following:

  • Americans have rejected the notion of a national police force for over 200 years. The FBI was not established as a law-enforcement agency until 1933, precisely because the republic wanted to limit the authority of those whom protect our civil liberties.
  • The FBI is designed to be as transparent as possible for the purpose of protecting the nation, as well as the rights and liberties enshrined in the Constitution. The oversight provided by Congress, the courts, and others have ensured the FBI did not evolve into a secret police force operating in the "Perpetual Black."

  • While England's MI-5 might be viewed as a panacea, it needs to be examined in light of the long, painful history of its operations in Northern Ireland. Moreover, MI-5 didn't protect England from the London Subway bombings and other acts of terrorism.
  • It would be difficult, if not impossible, for a myriad of state, local, and federal law-enforcement officials to have effective liaison with a secret domestic police operation.
  • A painful lesson learned from 9/11 is that the bifurcation of our intelligence and law-enforcement competencies leads to "stove piping" of information—a formula for disaster. Creating a separate secret-police organization would revive that failed model—weakening and balkanizing the law-enforcement and intelligence communities, rather than creating a united, seamless effort.
  • While many terrorism and legal experts have weighed in, the most qualified critics are the Brits themselves. If fact, many senior British law-enforcement officials criticize the MI-5 model and prefer the FBI's dual criminal and intelligence/terrorism roles.

This isn't to say the FBI can't do a better job integrating these disciplines and more broadly coordinating within the larger intelligence and law enforcement communities. Yet the fact these structures don't always perform seamlessly doesn't suggest the current process is dysfunctional.

Having devoted a considerable amount of my life in the "arena," I am confident the dedicated men and women of the FBI will continue to perform at a very high professional level to protect this great nation, while adhering to constitutional principles and the rule of law. 

 


Follow the FBI on Twitter @ FBIPressOffice

Main image credits: wikipedia
Click here to see all news from this author/company

Filed Under: Crime, Politics, PRESS RELEASE, TERRORISM

RUSH PR NEWS newswire and press release services at rushprnews.com / Anne Howard annehowardpublicist.com

Content- Legal Responsibility - All material is copyrighted - You may repost but you MUST link back to the original post on your page and acknowledge Rush PR News as the news source. Rush PR News is not legally and/or morally responsible for content of press releases, opinions expressed or fact-checking.

Rush PR News cannot be held legally responsible for material published and distributed through its newswire service or published in its press-room and therefore cannot be sued for published material. Third-party must be contacted directly to dispute content.

Rush PR News is not the contact for material published.

RSSFeed PRESS & SOCIAL MEDIA RELEASES

Zikto taking award-winning Arki to Startup Nations Summit

Seoul, Korea 11/22/14 · Zikto taking award-winning Arki to Startup Nations Summit The...

The End of Transparency? Don't be a fraud target

Carrollton, TX 11/18/14 · - Over the years, progressive and productive societies...

Ultraseal international in finals of Midlands Business Awards 2015

Coventry, UK 11/14/14 · Ultraseal International, which exports to the automotive supply...

Arki: Hot New Wearable Tech Setting a Cracking Pace on Kickstarter

San Francisco, CA 11/14/14 · Update for November 21: 412 Backers $90,034 pledged...

UpWest Labs Unveils Details of Its Eighth Batch of Startups, Ranging From Genetics to 3D Design

Palo Alto, California 11/11/14 · Accelerator continues to support innovative entrepreneurs with its...

Modern Casting Impregnation helps automakers to avoid warranty claims on engines

Novi, MI 11/11/14 · Automakers can save money and avoid costly warranty...

The Evolution of Walking: Wearable Tech steps up to a new level

San Francisco, CA 11/11/14 · Arki: Finally Wearable Meets Fashion – Wearable technology is one of 2014’s...

GeneSegues Awarded $1 Million Phase II NIH/NCI Research Contract for Nanoencapsulated RNAi Cancer Therapeutic

MINNEAPOLIS, MN 11/10/14 · Highly Competitive NIH Program Validates Potential of GS-10...

More Than 400 .Onion Addresses Targeted as Part of Global Enforcement Action on Tor Network

WASHINGTON 11/07/14 · More Than 400 .Onion Addresses, Including Dozens of...

Learn about Wine in Your Pjs - A New Kind of Wine Class

SAUSALITO, CA. 11/04/14 · The Wine Key announced today it's first virtual...

XCEL Professional Services Has Made a Huge Change to Move Our Company Forward

Calgary, AB 11/04/14 · Introducing Rob Hay: The New President of XCEL...

Furries and Despair – two-man show at Canessa Gallery, November 7 Wild is beautiful

San Francisco, CA 11/03/14 · The show  "Furries and Despair" at Canessa Gallery...

Ristech Completes Acquisition of Kirtas Technologies Inc.

Victor, NY. 11/03/14 · With the acquisition of Kirtas Technology, Ristech increases...

Signed, sealed, delivered: Email best practices

San Francisco, CA 10/31/14 · Email is the original Web app. Born in...